TFSA, RRSP, or Non-Registered Account? The Strategic Order for Saving in Quebec

Some time ago, I came across the case of a man in his thirties making $90,000 a year who was asking for advice on how to invest $10,000 he wanted to save. He had just opened an RRSP account a year prior and would like to buy a house or apartment in the medium term. He mentioned that he knew the FHSA was perfect for that, but wondered: what was the best investment strategy?

As many are well aware, owning property or real estate for quite a few people in Quebec equates to securing long-term financial stability. Therefore, I gather that the protagonist of this case, whom we will call Pierre, wants to acquire his property with this exact purpose in mind.

The most obvious strategy for Pierre would be to prioritize the FHSA with $8,000 for its double tax benefit and put the remainder into the RRSP. By saving in these two accounts, his taxes will be reduced, allowing him to reinvest his tax refund to keep saving the following year. When saving to buy a property, the ideal guideline is to prioritize the FHSA first (up to $8,000 per year, with a lifetime limit of $40,000) to take advantage of the double tax benefit: a deduction upon contribution and zero tax upon withdrawal for a home purchase.

Furthermore, making aggressive short-term investments is not advisable, as you run the risk of incurring losses. It is preferable to maintain investment horizons aligned with each goal within appropriate accounts, such as the RRSP, to generate solid long-term gains.

The Strategy Behind the Savings Order

People often think the golden rule is simple: save, save, and keep saving. But it is not just about accumulating; it is about knowing where to save and when to invest in the best possible way.

In Quebec, how you save your money is just as important as the amount you manage to accumulate. Should you max out your RRSP first? Let your TFSA keep growing? Tap into your non-registered accounts? The wrong savings order can cost you thousands of dollars in unnecessary taxes.

Here is the ultimate guide to understanding the strategic order of your contributions and withdrawals:

1. The TFSA

The Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) is your best ally for maintaining financial flexibility. Although it does not offer an immediate tax deduction at the time of deposit—unlike the RRSP—it becomes the "silent hero" thanks to its massive strategic advantages upon withdrawal. Plus, you recover your contribution room the following year after making any withdrawal.

• Why use it?: TFSA withdrawals are 100% tax-free and have no impact on your declared net income. Moreover, if your income falls into the lower tax brackets (below roughly $50,000), it is often much smarter to max out the TFSA before the RRSP. This way, you reserve your RRSP room for when you earn more and the deductions are juicier, while your money is already growing tax-free in the TFSA.
• The strategic advantage: It does not affect your tax credits (such as the federal age tax credit or Quebec’s provincial tax credit) or your government benefits (such as the Guaranteed Income Supplement or Old Age Security).
• Wealth transfer: The TFSA is an extraordinary tool for estate planning, as it can be transferred to a surviving spouse completely tax-free (as a successor holder) or to heirs with minimal or zero tax impact.

2. The RRSP

Much like the FHSA, one of its greatest advantages is reducing your current tax burden, which is why it tends to be the primary savings vehicle for Quebecers. However, looking ahead to retirement, every dollar withdrawn will be added directly to your taxable income for the year, which could suddenly bump up your tax bracket with both Revenu Québec and the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA).

• The strategy: Contribute when your salary and tax bracket are high, and withdraw the money during retirement, when your annual income is typically lower and you therefore pay a lower tax rate. It is often wise to make strategic withdrawals from your RRSP before age 71 (between ages 60 and 70) to smooth out your tax bill over several years.
• Income splitting: As we explained in our article "The Balance of Present and Future: Sacrifice or Strategy?", if one spouse earns more, they can contribute to a spousal RRSP (REER du conjoint) to lower the current tax bill and balance out future income.
• Watch out for future benefits: Too high a taxable income in retirement can claw back your government benefits, such as Old Age Security (OAS).

3. The Non-Registered Account: Flexibility Above All

As a general rule, it is typically advantageous to start putting money into your non-registered investment accounts for specific projects or once you have maxed out your contribution limits in registered accounts.

• Why?: Only capital gains, interest income, and dividends are taxable. Additionally, these accounts feature favorable tax treatment for capital gains: unlike employment or RRSP income, in a non-registered account, only 50% of the gains are subject to tax.
• The tax advantage: In Canada and Quebec, the capital gains inclusion rate enjoys preferential tax treatment compared to future RRSP withdrawals, which are taxed as ordinary income.
• Tax-Loss Harvesting: Unlike the TFSA or RRSP, if you sell an investment at a loss in a non-registered account, you can use that loss to offset capital gains from the same year, carry it back up to three years, or carry it forward to reduce future taxes.

4. Is There a One-Size-Fits-All Rule?

The short answer is no. The ideal order depends heavily on the unique factors of your situation:

• Your income sources, long-term plans, and the benefits you will receive during retirement (for example, a workplace pension or QPP).
• Whether or not you have a spouse (to optimize income splitting and allocation).
• Your wealth transfer goals (inheritance and estate planning).
• Whether you have medium-term projects during retirement and need liquidity for specific goals, such as buying a car, renovating your home, or taking a major trip.

This is where dynamic planning truly proves its value. It is not about applying a rigid formula, but rather simulating the real-world impact of every decision year after year.

Conclusion

Optimizing your savings order ensures that your capital grows, lasts longer, and stays in your pockets instead of vanishing into unnecessary taxes.

Do not leave the planning of your financial future to chance. Saving in the wrong account can spike your taxes or diminish your government benefits in Quebec.

👉 Use the AuraPlan.ca platform to simulate your retirement strategies and discover the most efficient path to your retirement starting today!